Warwick experts help West Midlands Police convict killers

Unique collaboration sees cutting edge research used to prove murder cases

Futuristic 3D scanning technology at WMG , University of Warwick is helping West Midlands Police to convict killers thanks to a pioneering new partnership which is providing juries with microscopic evidence previously beyond the reach of forensic testing.

Detective Superintendent Mark Payne (left) and Professor Mark Williams (right) at WMG’s metrology facility

Last month, Lorenzo Simon was sentenced to life in prison for the barbaric murder of a housemate whose body he dissected and stuffed inside suitcases he later hurled into Birmingham Canal, with help from his girlfriend Michelle Bird.

Crucially detectives recovered part of the victim’s humerus from an oil drum in the couple’s garden – used as a furnace to destroy evidence – which experts from WMG, at the University of Warwick, proved was a seamless fit with a limb found in the case.

And the same 3D scanning technique – which provides image resolution 43,000 times more detailed that a hospital CT scan – also proved laceration links between a saw recovered from the canal-bed and marks found on other bones.

Professor Mark Williams (right) shows Detective Superintendent Mark Payne (left) a 3D printed model of murder victim Michael Spalding’s humerus

WMG is a leader in 3D technologies , collaborating regularly with partners from industry areas including aerospace and automotive, where atomic material failures can have catastrophic consequences – but this is the first time a police force in the UK has embraced the science to support its investigations.

The cutting-edge research centre has worked with West Midlands Police on four cases to date, including three murder trials, the most recent being the brutal killing of Michael Spalding at the Smethwick house he shared with Simon and Bird.

Nine pieces of bone were repeatedly x-rayed at a range of angles with the many thousands of images collated using specialist software to produce the 3D ultra-scans.

They were then displayed on a virtual reality 3D video wall, allowing detectives, police forensic experts and crown prosecutors to examine the digital images in remarkable depth.

Professor Mark Williams (left) and Detective Superintendent Mark Payne (right) look at a scan of murder victim Michael Spalding’s humerus on WMG’s 3d virtual reality video wall

Professor Mark Williams , Head of Product Evaluation Technologies at WMG, said: “A black lump resembling a large piece of coal was found in the oil drum and our scans revealed it contained the top part of the victim’s humerus, fused inside a mass of molten debris.

“The bone had been sawn and snapped. After scanning body parts in the cases we found it was a perfect jigsaw fit to another piece of bone and could show in minute detail – down to one 17,000th of a millimetre or half a hair’s breadth – the cuts on the bones.

“That helped officers match the serrated edge of the saw to many of the indents and showed they’d been inflicted with a blade width of 1.4mm. And we made exact 3D print replicas of the bone to demonstrate the evidence to the jury.

“This combination of micro computerised tomography scanning, 3D printing and 3D virtual reality truly makes the process a UK first.”

Unlike traditional post mortems carried out by pathologists the scanning is non- and can produce high-definition 3D scans of bones or organs without the need for an invasive procedure.

Such advanced automation doesn’t come cheap and, against a backdrop of continued public sector funding cuts, the multi-million pound scanning equipment and associated software is beyond the fiscal reach of police forces.

However, this unique collaboration gives West Midlands Police access not just to the technology, but also some of the UK’s leading lights in the field of digital forensics.

In return the force funds a three-year Forensic PhD placement at WMG to look at further developing the science and expanding its capability.

Professor Mark Williams (left) and Detective Superintendent Mark Payne (right) use a 3D virtual reality wall to analyse murder victim Michael Spalding’s humerus

Professor Williams added: “It’s a perfect collaboration and hugely rewarding being involved in major crime investigations knowing our work is helping convict offenders and secure justice for grieving families.

“But it’s not about trying to prove someone is responsible for a crime...it’s about helping to understand a case and getting to the truth. The technology can show whether a death was accidental or murder.

“The way we generated the evidence for this case, from the scanning and visualisation technology, through to the 3D printing, is absolutely unique.”

3D scanning evidence was also influential in convicting a Birmingham man who murdered his estranged wife last year at their family home in Pype Hayes.

Andrew Leigh claimed he found former partner Luan Leigh collapsed on the floor and that his ham-fisted attempts at CPR were responsible for bruising found around her throat.

However, scans revealed damage to the woman’s larynx – in detail beyond the capabilities of medical CT scans – that proved beyond doubt the victim had been forcibly strangled. He was subsequently jailed for a minimum of 25 years.

West Midlands Police Detective Superintendent Mark Payne is leading the Warwick collaboration. He said: It’s a fantastic development in the field of forensics and, as we’ve proved in the few cases to date, can be crucial in helping us uncover the truth behind some of our most serious crimes.”

Professor Mark Williams at WMG’s metrology facility

The 10-strong team of experts at WMG, whose backgrounds are in industry and research, are now building on their current capabilities by running trials into the 3D modelling of entire crime scenes.

Detectives believe the high-resolution computer graphics could assist their investigations and make it much easier to present evidence to a jury, eliminating any confusion over witness testimonies.


You can click on each image to the photographs in high resolution.